Why should a Baroque piece be played differently from a Romantic one, and what conventions make a performance stylistically convincing?
Perform in a style-appropriate way, applying the performance-practice conventions of the relevant period, including ornamentation, articulation, tempo flexibility and idiomatic technique
A focused answer to the H2 Music performing outcome on performance practice. Period-appropriate conventions of ornamentation, articulation, dynamics and tempo flexibility from Baroque to Romantic, and applying historically informed choices to make a performance stylistically convincing.
Reviewed by: AI editorial process; not yet individually human-reviewed
Have a quick question? Jump to the Q&A page
Jump to a section
What this dot point is asking
SEAB wants you to perform in a style-appropriate way, applying the performance-practice conventions of the relevant period: ornamentation, articulation, dynamics, tempo flexibility and idiomatic technique. The central insight is that a score is incomplete and period-specific: composers assumed conventions they did not write down, and these differ sharply between the Baroque, Classical and Romantic eras. Your task is to know those conventions and apply them, so a Baroque piece sounds Baroque and a Romantic piece sounds Romantic.
The answer
The musical concept: what performance practice is
Performance practice is the body of conventions, often unwritten in the score, that governs how music of a given period and style was and should be performed. It covers ornamentation, articulation, dynamics, tempo flexibility, the instruments used and the playing technique. It matters because notation only sketches expression and reflects the assumptions of its time; applying the wrong era's conventions makes a performance stylistically false.
The technique: Baroque conventions
- Articulation: clear, often detached and clean part-playing, conceived for the harpsichord and early instruments.
- Dynamics: terraced (stepped between levels, including echo effects), rather than constant gradual swells, often achieved by adding or reducing voices.
- Ornamentation: trills, mordents, appoggiaturas and other ornaments are expected, partly improvised, and essential to the style.
- Tempo: steady, especially in dances, with only modest flexibility; frequently a basso continuo underpins the texture.
The technique: Classical and Romantic conventions
- Classical: balanced periodic phrasing, graded dynamics enabled by the fortepiano, cleaner homophonic textures, restrained rubato, and mostly notated (less improvised) ornaments.
- Romantic: a wide dynamic range, generous expressive rubato, rich legato and sustaining pedal on the modern piano, larger forces, and intense expressive shaping.
Applying it: historically informed choices
A stylistically convincing performance chooses articulation, dynamics, ornament realisation and tempo flexibility to match the period, ideally with awareness of the instruments and aesthetics the composer assumed.
Examples in context
Example 1. J. S. Bach, keyboard dances and fugues. Performed in a historically informed way, these call for clear, partly detached articulation, terraced dynamics, realised ornaments and a steady tempo, ideally with harpsichord touch in mind. They are the model for Baroque performance practice and contrast sharply with how a Romantic piece is played.
Example 2. Chopin, piano works. Chopin's music exemplifies Romantic practice: expressive rubato, a wide dynamic range, singing legato and subtle pedalling on the modern piano, and intense expressive shaping. Set against the Bach, it shows how performance-practice conventions transform the treatment of the written notes between periods.
Try this
Q1. Define performance practice and explain why it matters. [2 marks]
- Cue. It is the body of largely unwritten, period-specific conventions (ornamentation, articulation, dynamics, tempo, technique) governing how music should be performed; it matters because notation is incomplete and reflects its era's assumptions.
Q2. Describe how Baroque dynamics differ from Romantic dynamics. [2 marks]
- Cue. Baroque dynamics are terraced, stepping between distinct levels (with echo and changes of voicing); Romantic dynamics use a wide range with gradual expressive crescendos and diminuendos.
Q3. Explain two conventions you would apply to perform a Baroque piece convincingly. [3 marks]
- Cue. Use clear, partly detached articulation with little or no pedal; realise the ornaments (trills, mordents, appoggiaturas); keep terraced dynamics and a steady tempo. (Any two explained.)
Exam-style practice questions
Practice questions written in the style of SEAB exam questions on this dot point, with worked answer explainers. The year tag is the paper they imitate, not the source.
Original8 marksA student plays a Baroque keyboard dance with heavy sustained pedal, a thick legato throughout, large swelling crescendos and diminuendos on every phrase, and ignores the ornament signs. Explain why this is stylistically inappropriate for the Baroque, and describe how the same piece should be performed.Show worked answer →
Explain the problems. Heavy sustained pedalling and uniform thick legato suit a later, Romantic ideal, not the clearer Baroque texture, which was conceived for harpsichord (no sustaining pedal) and clean part-playing. Large graded crescendos on every phrase impose Romantic dynamic shaping on music whose dynamics were largely terraced (stepped between levels, often by adding or reducing voices or by echo). Ignoring the ornament signs omits an essential part of the Baroque style, where trills, mordents and appoggiaturas are expected and partly improvised.
Describe the appropriate performance. Use a lighter, more detached and clearly articulated touch with little or no pedal, terraced rather than constantly graded dynamics, a steady dance tempo with only modest flexibility, and realise the ornaments (trills, mordents, appoggiaturas) in keeping with Baroque convention.
Markers reward identifying the anachronistic pedalling, legato and graded dynamics, the omitted ornaments, and a correct account of Baroque practice (articulation, terraced dynamics, steady tempo, realised ornaments). The strongest answers connect the conventions to the instruments and aesthetics of the period.
Original12 marksExplain what is meant by performance practice and why it matters, and outline how performing conventions differ between the Baroque, Classical and Romantic periods. Refer to repertoire you have studied.Show worked answer →
Define performance practice. Performance practice is the body of conventions, often unwritten in the score, that governs how music of a given period and style was and should be performed: ornamentation, articulation, dynamics, tempo flexibility, instrumentation and technique. It matters because notation is incomplete and period-specific, so a stylistically convincing performance applies the conventions the composer assumed.
Contrast the periods. Baroque: clear articulation, terraced dynamics, expected and partly improvised ornamentation, steady tempo, harpsichord and early instruments, often a continuo. Classical: balanced phrasing, graded dynamics (the fortepiano), cleaner textures, restrained rubato, notated ornaments. Romantic: wide dynamic range, expressive rubato, rich legato and pedal on the modern piano, larger forces, and intense expressive shaping.
Use examples. A Bach dance or fugue for Baroque practice; a Mozart sonata for Classical; a Chopin or Brahms piece for Romantic.
Evaluate. Markers reward a clear definition, the reason it matters (incomplete, period-specific notation), and an accurate period-by-period contrast of conventions, with located examples. The strongest answers link the conventions to the instruments and aesthetics of each era.
Related dot points
- Interpret a score by making informed musical decisions about tempo, dynamics, phrasing and character, going beyond accurate notes to a coherent and communicative performance
A focused answer to the H2 Music performing outcome on interpretation. Reading beyond the notes, deciding tempo, dynamics, phrasing and character, distinguishing what the score fixes from what the performer chooses, and shaping a coherent, communicative reading.
- Perform with expression, shaping phrases and grading dynamics, and control articulation, including legato, staccato, accents and other touches, to communicate musical meaning
A focused answer to the H2 Music performing outcome on expression. Shaping phrases with direction and breath, grading dynamics within and across phrases, and controlling articulation (legato, staccato, accents, slurs) to project musical meaning and structure.
- Demonstrate technical control and quality tone production, including accuracy, evenness, intonation, fluent technique, and a consistent, well-projected sound
A focused answer to the H2 Music performing outcome on technique and tone. Accuracy and evenness, intonation, fluent and reliable technique, breath or bow and finger control, and producing a consistent, well-projected and quality tone as the foundation of interpretation.
- Perform effectively in ensemble, maintaining ensemble and balance, listening and responding to other parts, and adapting between leading, accompanying and equal roles
A focused answer to the H2 Music performing outcome on ensemble. Keeping together (ensemble), balance and blend, listening and responding, following and leading, the accompanist's role, and adapting between melody, accompaniment and equal-partner roles.
- Account for the features of the Classical style, including periodic phrasing, the Alberti bass and clear tonal structure, and explain sonata form as its central design
A focused answer to the H2 Music outcome on the Classical era. Periodic phrasing, balance and clarity, the Alberti bass, the move from continuo to homophony, and sonata form as the central Classical structure with its tonal drama.