Back to the full dot-point answer
SingaporeEnglish LiteratureQuick questions
Comparative and Contextual Study
Quick questions on Structuring the comparative essay explained: H2 Literature in English
9short Q&A pairs drawn directly from our worked dot-point answer. For full context and worked exam questions, read the parent dot-point page.
What is plan before you write?Show answer
Under exam conditions the few minutes spent planning pay for themselves. A workable plan has three parts: a comparative thesis in one sentence, three or four points of comparison as paragraph headings, and a one-line note of the evidence from each text for each point. This plan guarantees from the outset that every paragraph will handle both texts and that the essay will compare rather than summarise. Writing without it is the surest route to a "two halves" essay.
What is open with a comparative thesis?Show answer
The thesis must already compare. The reliable shape is "both texts present X, but where A does P, B does Q", which commits you to a shared element and a difference. This single sentence is the spine of the essay; every paragraph develops it. A thesis that describes only one text, or that is too general to argue, leaves the structure with nothing comparative to carry.
What are build point-by-point, integrated paragraphs?Show answer
The body is organised by points of comparison, not by text. Each paragraph follows the same internal shape: a comparative topic sentence, close analysis of the first text's method, a turn to the second with a connective ("by contrast", "in the same way, though"), and a sentence that weighs the two. This is the unit that does the comparing. Three or four such paragraphs, each on a distinct point, give a comparative essay its shape.
What is a non-comparative thesis?Show answer
Opening with a claim about one text, so the structure has nothing comparative to develop.
What is unbalanced coverage?Show answer
Lavishing analysis on one text and neglecting the other, often because the plan did not require evidence from both under each point.
What is a restating conclusion?Show answer
Summarising the two readings instead of weighing them, wasting the essay's last chance to argue and reach a judgement.
What is q1?Show answer
What three parts make a usable comparative essay plan under exam conditions? [2 marks]
What is q2?Show answer
Why is the comparative topic sentence the structural lever of comparison? [2 marks]
What is q3?Show answer
What should a comparative conclusion do instead of restating the readings? [3 marks]